Why Remodeling Your Existing Pool Can Be a Smarter Investment Than Building a New One

If you already have a backyard pool, you’ve got a head start on creating the ultimate outdoor oasis. But over time, finishes fade, equipment wears out, and designs go out of style. Many homeowners start to wonder: Should I remodel the pool I already have or start from scratch with a new one?

At S.H. Creel Pools, we’ve worked with homeowners across Georgia and Tennessee who face that same question—and in many cases, remodeling or refurbishing an existing pool turns out to be the smarter, faster, and more affordable investment. Here’s why.

1. Remodeling Saves Thousands Compared to a Complete Rebuild

A brand-new pool build can cost significantly more than remodeling. When you already have a pool shell, plumbing, and structure in place, you’re saving on the most expensive parts of construction.

A professional pool remodel in Georgia or Tennessee can often transform your pool for a fraction of the cost of starting over. You can resurface, update tile and coping, add new lighting, upgrade filtration, and even reshape sections of your pool—all without tearing everything out.

For example, many homeowners we’ve worked with in Chattanooga, Nashville, and North Georgia have saved 30–50% compared to the cost of a brand-new build, while achieving a result that feels brand new.

2. Refurbishing Adds Real Value to Your Property

When done right, a pool remodel doesn’t just refresh your backyard—it boosts your home’s resale value. A modernized, energy-efficient pool adds instant curb appeal and gives future buyers confidence that the pool has been properly maintained and upgraded.

A newly finished pool with updated tile, decking, and water features can make your home stand out in competitive real estate markets like Atlanta suburbs, Dalton, or Franklin, TN. Potential buyers often prefer a beautifully renovated pool over an older or neglected one that would require major work.

In short: a pool renovation can turn your existing backyard into one of your home’s most valuable assets.

3. Modern Equipment Upgrades Can Cut Energy Costs

One of the biggest benefits of remodeling your pool instead of starting over is the ability to upgrade your pool’s technology. Older pools often use outdated pumps, filters, and lighting that consume more energy and require more maintenance.

When you remodel, you can add:

• Variable-speed pumps that cut energy use by up to 80%.

• LED lighting that transforms your pool’s ambiance while reducing electricity costs.

• Automated systems you can control from your smartphone.

• Energy-efficient heaters and filtration systems designed for the Southern climate.

Homeowners across Georgia and Tennessee who have updated their pool systems often see noticeable savings on utility bills and reduced maintenance time—making their backyard fun and functional again.

4. Remodeling Lets You Reimagine the Look and Feel

Tastes change over time. Maybe your pool was built in the 1990s and features old tile patterns, rough plaster, or basic concrete decking. A remodel gives you the chance to modernize your design and bring your dream pool to life—without the full price tag of new construction.

Today’s pool remodels can include:

• Sleek pebble or quartz finishes for a modern look

• Natural stone or travertine decking upgrades

• Waterfalls, tanning ledges, or fire features

• LED lighting effects that set the mood after dark

Many Tennessee pool refurbishments also include expanding patio spaces, adding outdoor kitchens, or integrating new landscaping—creating an entire backyard retreat.

5. Less Downtime, More Swim Time

A full pool build can take months, especially when you factor in permitting, excavation, and construction. Remodeling an existing pool, however, typically takes a few weeks, depending on the size and complexity of the project.

That means you can enjoy your updated pool faster—just in time for those warm Georgia or Tennessee summers. Whether you want to surprise your family with a refreshed backyard or get your space ready for next season’s gatherings, remodeling gives you a faster path to enjoyment.

6. You Can Keep the Layout You Love—And Improve Everything Else

If your current pool’s shape and layout still fit your lifestyle, there’s no need to start over. Many homeowners love their existing pool footprint but want to make it more modern, functional, or easier to maintain.

With a remodel, you can:

• Add steps, benches, or shallow tanning areas

• Replace outdated coping or tile

• Improve safety with new handrails or slip-resistant surfaces

• Refresh aging plaster with a long-lasting finish

This allows you to preserve what works while upgrading everything that doesn’t—saving both time and money.

7. Remodeling Makes Maintenance Easier and More Reliable

Older pools often suffer from inefficient plumbing, cracks, or outdated materials that lead to constant repairs. A pool refurbishment can resolve these issues permanently by addressing leaks, resurfacing the interior, and modernizing your pool systems.

When our team at S.H. Creel Pools renovates a pool, we ensure the structure and equipment are not only beautiful but also built to last for decades. You’ll spend less time worrying about upkeep and more time enjoying your outdoor space.

When to Choose a New Pool Instead

While remodeling makes sense for most homeowners, there are cases where a new build might be necessary—like when the existing structure has extensive damage, poor placement, or doesn’t meet your size or depth preferences.

Our experienced design and construction team can evaluate your current pool and help you decide whether a remodel or new build makes the most sense for your goals and budget.

Final Thoughts: A Remodel Can Be a Smart, Beautiful, and Cost-Effective Choice

Whether you’re in North Georgia, Chattanooga, Knoxville, or Middle Tennessee, your backyard pool doesn’t have to be torn out to make it feel brand new. A thoughtful remodel can transform your existing pool into a modern, energy-efficient, and stylish retreat—often in less time and for far less cost than starting from scratch.

At S.H. Creel Pools, we specialize in custom pool remodels and renovations designed to make your current backyard better than ever. From resurfacing and lighting upgrades to full-scale transformations, we bring new life to existing pools across the Southeast.

Ready to fall back in love with your pool?👉 Request a quote today